Prosper Bender from Quebec City to Boston

Several months ago I provided a brief glimpse of the life and times of Prosper Bender (1844-1917), a Quebec-born physician, littérateur, and intercultural broker.

Bender spent much of his life championing unpopular causes. Though he may have delighted in being a contrarian, there is little to suggest that he was a girouette, a weather vane. Ceaselessly he endeavored to bridge the misconceptions and suspicions separating French Canadians and their English-speaking neighbors. His body of work remains as relevant today as it was in the late nineteenth century. It continues to illuminate the challenges facing the young Canadian federation, suggesting that the British North America Act could have proven as short-lived as prior constitutions. More significantly, it points to the never-ending task of fostering amicable relations amid cultural differences.

Prosper Bender (ca 1895)
Prosper Bender / A. R. Roy [Vers 1895], Collection Centre d’archives de Québec, Bibliothèque et Archives nationales du Québec, P1000,S4,D83,PB36
From Quebec to New England, my path has followed Bender’s in many respects. But only this past summer did I consciously begin to retrace his steps. While in Quebec City, my wife and I set about exploring rue d’Aiguillon, or, as some English denizens once knew it, Ding-a-Long Street.

The street stretches southwesterly from the ramparts of the Upper Town, only a short walk from the National Assembly. There Bender made his home and saw patients—perhaps for a decade, perhaps more—before he abruptly moved to Boston in 1882.

Heatherington Bakery (rue d'Aiguillon)
Québec, Québec – Maisons rue d’Aiguillon [Vers 1900], Fonds Hethrington, Bibliothèque et Archives nationales du Québec, E6,S8,SS6,P65
Where on rue d’Aiguillon? For the moment, the question is complicated by a renumbering of civic addresses in the late 1870s. As a result, fire insurance maps point us to two different locations. One of those, at the corner of Saint-Augustin, is now the site of a modern apartment building. The other, on Côte Sainte-Geneviève, seems a likelier candidate, as the two addresses given to Bender’s house could both correspond to this building. It also happens to be facing his friend Faucher de Saint-Maurice’s house, also on the corner of d’Aiguillon and Saint-Geneviève. From a researcher’s perspective, it is also more appealing because the building that stands on the site now is probably the one that Bender would have inhabited.

Faucher House Quebec City (corner of Sainte-Geneviève and d'Aiguillon)
Faucher House in Quebec City (corner of Sainte-Geneviève and d’Aiguillon) (P. Lacroix)
Bender house Quebec City (corner of Saint-Geneviève and d'Aiguillon)
A house where Bender may have lived in Quebec City (corner of Saint-Geneviève and d’Aiguillon) (P. Lacroix)

If the latter location does, through further research, prove to be Bender’s former residence, we hope to have the City of Quebec honor him with one of its “Ici vécut” historical plaques, such as the one gracing Faucher’s house.

As for his lengthy stay in Boston, extending to 1908, Bender’s whereabouts require much less speculation. Perhaps from the moment of his move, he lodged at the prestigious Hotel Vendome on Commonwealth Avenue. Although not necessarily an evident choice for him, Bender had previously visited the Northeast; he was preceded in Boston by other Canadian intellectuals who may have whetted his appetite. What is clear is that he quickly found his footing there, even joining a committee venturing to organize an international exhibition in the city. A decade later, having nearly fulfilled residency requirements for naturalization, he related an anecdote that expressed his view of the great Yankee hub:

A woman who had just lost her husband desired to have a tombstone placed over his grave, with some choice inscription, and she requested suggestions to that effect. Several were submitted to her taste, but all failed to meet its fastidious requirements. Finally the supply of sentiment being somewhat exhausted, it was asked if she would not like the simple, old epitaph: “Gone to a Better Land.” “Oh! no,” she quickly replied, in a tone of surprise, mingled with some indignation, “that would never do; why he lived all his life in Boston!”

– Bender in The New England Magazine (1892)

As for the Vendome, it was a sought-after address; within its halls were held grand dinners organized by and for the well-to-do (see here and here). Well after Bender’s departure, following the Second World War, other hotels began to eclipse it. At the turn of the 1970s, renovations that would convert the hotel into luxury apartments promised the building a new lease on life. But in the course of these renovations the Vendome earned the infamy with which it is still associated: a fire broke out in June 1972 and in battling the blaze nine firefighters lost their lives, the deadliest day in the history of the Boston Fire Department. With reason, the likes of Bender who called the Vendome home have largely been obscured.

Hotel Vendome (Boston)
Hotel Vendome, Commonwealth Ave., Boston [c. 1903], Library of Congress, Prints and Photographs Division, PAN US GEOG – Massachusetts no. 75 (E size) [P&P]
Newspaper ads dated from Bender’s return to Quebec City, in 1908, show that he set up shop in the former residence of the Duke of Kent, in the shadow of the Château Frontenac and across Haldimand Street from the Hôtel Saint-Louis. (The Kent House was recently home to the French consulate in Quebec City; it has since been redeveloped into luxury lodging.) A fire insurance map from 1910 indicates that Bender shared the building with photographers, tea rooms, and “curios.” His place of residence has yet to be ascertained, but his office was evidently prime real estate at any season. Once again the physician fixed himself near the centers of political power and culture.

Duke of Kent House French Consulate Quebec City Prosper Bender
Duke of Kent House while it served as the French Consulate in Quebec City (Wikimedia Commons)

One can easily read too much into Bender from his place in turn-of-the-century urban geographies. Both he and Faucher tell of long rides with friends into the countryside around Quebec City; there was a deep affection for those rural landscapes and their people. They provided inspiration to Bender in his writing.

It remains no less that on d’Aiguillon his salon served as the synapse of French-Canadian intellectual and cultural life. In Massachusetts, he may have become one of those individuals who, according to Thomas D’Arcy McGee, assumed “Bostonian culture to be the worship of the future, and the American democratic system to be the manifestly destined form of government for all the civilized world, new as well as old.” Boston was indeed a center of culture. Ever ready to play the contrarian, Bender sought to be where ideas circulated, where power was exerted. In both locations, we know that he lived in luxury, truly inhabiting the role of a middle-class man-about-town.

You can learn more about Bender in “Seeking an ‘Entente Cordiale’: Prosper Bender, French Canada, and Intercultural Brokership in the Nineteenth Century,” Journal of Canadian Studies (spring 2018), 381-403, accessible here.


Addendum, December 2018: Since writing this, I have had the pleasure of hearing from Quebec City’s Service de la culture, du patrimoine et des relations internationales. Quite helpfully, some diligent public servants undertook research and found that Bender’s home was actually at the corner of Saint-Augustin and d’Aiguillon in the 1870s, a building that no longer exists. Nevertheless, Bender is now in the Quebec City database from which the names of streets and other public landmarks are drawn. He may yet have his day in the sun.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *